Lions GM Brad Holmes have a reach problem in the NFL Draft And has made decision to…

Detroit Lions General Manager Brad Holmes is once again under scrutiny for his drafting strategy, particularly concerning perceived “reaches” in the 2025 NFL Draft. Critics point to selections like wide receiver Isaac TeSlaa, whom the Lions traded up to draft in the third round—a move considered a 101-pick reach compared to consensus projections . This decision has contributed to the Lions receiving predominantly negative draft grades, with six out of ten evaluators ranking them 25th or lower . (Does Lions GM Brad Holmes have a reach problem in the NFL Draft?, NFL Draft grades 2025 roundup: Detroit Lions rank among worst classes)

Holmes’ approach, however, is not without precedent. In previous drafts, he has made unconventional picks that have both faltered and flourished. Notably, selections like tight end Sam LaPorta and running back Jahmyr Gibbs, initially viewed as reaches, have developed into key contributors. Conversely, picks such as Brodric Martin and Colby Sorsdal have yet to meet expectations . (Rank Brad Holmes’ Drafts (2021-2024) : r/detroitlions – Reddit, Does Lions GM Brad Holmes have a reach problem in the NFL Draft?)

Despite the criticism, Holmes remains steadfast in his philosophy. He emphasizes selecting players who align with the team’s culture and values over adhering strictly to consensus rankings. “We’re not going to reach on players just to fill a position,” Holmes stated in a pre-draft press conference, underscoring his commitment to drafting based on fit rather than need . (Detroit Lions GM Brad Holmes preaches patience in NFL draft)

This strategy has seen the Lions focus on building a roster that embodies toughness and resilience, traits exemplified by their selection of three players from the University of Georgia in the 2025 draft—guard Tate Ratledge, safety Dan Jackson, and wide receiver Dominic Lovett . (Lions GM Brad Holmes drafts 3 Georgia players and makes history …)

As the Lions prepare for the upcoming season, the effectiveness of Holmes’ draft strategy will be closely monitored. While some of his picks have defied expectations, others have validated the concerns of skeptics. The 2025 draft class will serve as the latest test of Holmes’ unconventional approach and its impact on the Lions’ pursuit of sustained success.